From Cassettes to Streaming: Which Era of Music Do You Miss Most?

What if having everything actually made us appreciate music less?

Streaming changed the way we listen forever, but in 2026, people are rewinding. Literally. Searches for portable cassette players have hit record highs, secondhand iPods are selling out, and wired headphones are back in fashion. Turns out, the era of endless choice has left a lot of us quietly longing for something simpler.

I grew up with cassettes and CDs, and I remember the effort that went into it. Recording songs off the radio, finger hovering over the pause button so you didn’t accidentally capture the DJ talking over the intro. Handwriting lyrics into notebooks so you could memorise every word. Spending an entire afternoon compiling the perfect playlist for any potential mood.

There was something powerful about that control. Happy? You had a tape for that. Heartbroken? Cue the ballads. Desperate to disappear from the world around you? Put your favourite band’s mixtape on, press play, and suddenly you were somewhere else entirely.

The numbers don’t lie

The cassette era was patient and creative. You couldn’t skip a song without fast-forwarding and hoping for the best. The CD era brought clarity and permanence. Albums felt like complete works, meant to be experienced from track one to the last. The iPod changed everything again. A thousand songs in your pocket felt like a superpower, and the click wheel became one of the most satisfying things your thumb had ever touched.

According to Google Trends, searches for wired headphones and portable cassette players have hit all-time highs this year. Perhaps the most telling detail? Generation Z is the top audience searching for iPods, a generation that grew up with streaming, is actively seeking out a device that predates them.

Ben McEachen, who was working as a music reviewer when the iPod first launched, remembers his reaction to seeing one for the first time.

Hope 103.2 is proudly supported by

“My first thought was, why would I want that as well as my Discman?”

The Hope Team’s Favourite Era

We asked the Hope 103.2 team which era of music listening they love most and the answers did not disappoint.

Laura Bennett’s memory takes her straight back to childhood: “Going for bushwalks as a kid on the fire trail behind our house, sharing an earbud each with a friend while listening to TLC. That was the dream”.

Chris Jolly remembers saving up from his first part-time job just out of high school to buy a Sony Discman, carrying it everywhere on the bus, at the library, walking to a mate’s place. And for those rare moments when a bag wasn’t an option, “I had to make sure I chose the right CD”.

Lucy, our marketing mind, was a CD Walkman devotee and hasn’t forgotten its greatest quirk. “It jumped when you walked, so each song was a sort of remix of the original.” Her old wired headphones have since been commandeered by her 14-year-old. Full circle.

Brittany, our community connector, loved the independence the Discman gave her. No fighting anyone for listening rights, her own tunes tucked neatly in her bag. “It always seemed to give moody teenager, main character vibes.” Her standout memory? Holding it perfectly flat in the car so the CD wouldn’t skip over bumps.

Derrick, our podcast producer, never quite made it to the Discman era. “It was way out of my reach!” But cassettes? That’s where his story begins. His first was MLTR’s Paint My Love, played so many times the tape eventually came undone. Sad times, but the best kind.

Beth, our digital marketing whiz, comes with a reality check on one of the great marketing claims of the 90s. She got a Sony Discman with anti-shock technology in her late teens and headed out running around the neighbourhood. “When they marketed it as anti-shock, they just meant it would only stop playing occasionally instead of all the time. I can confirm it was not that quick to recover.” Best thing she owned at the time, though. No question.

Still listening

Maybe streaming isn’t the villain of this story. Having every song ever recorded available in seconds is still remarkable, and most of us aren’t ready to give that up either.

Perhaps what this moment is really telling us is that we want both. The convenience of the present and the intention of the past. The endless library and the single perfect mixtape. The algorithm and the afternoon spent curating your own playlist for a mood that hadn’t even arrived yet.

Music has always been somewhere we go, not just something we play. And no matter the format, that feeling doesn’t seem to be going anywhere.

Feature image: Canva Pro